All spirits Whiskey Agave Rum Gin Vodka Brandy Liqueur Everything else Taste finder Brands

Distillery & brand

J. Mattingly 84 bottlings

84 bottlings from J. Mattingly out of USA, mostly Bourbon. The range averages 3.79 out of 5 across 37 rated bottles.

3.78median score

$$$$typical price

80ratings

Best picks Highest rated Most reviewed Best value Under $50

Filters

1 filter on Clear all

Whiskey 84

Under $30 $300 and up

Tiers, not live prices: Under $30 through $300 and up.

4.5+ Exceptional 4.2+ Very good 4.0+ Good 3.5+ Decent Any rating

Anyone 25 people 100 people 500 people

A thin score moves a lot with one more review.

Bourbon 36 Other Whiskey 26 Rye 17 American Blended Whiskey 3 Blended 1 Flavored Whiskey 1

USA 84

Kentucky 36 Indiana 5 Kwntucky 1 MGP 1

ABV %

Age (years)

Age filters skip bottles with no age statement.

Clear

Showing 25–48 of 84 bottles

#25

J. Mattingly

J. Mattingly 1845 Private Barrel Select Bourbon "Midnight Loon"

Whiskey Bourbon Kentucky 56.5% ABV

3.77

1 rating

$$$$ $100 to $300 Luxury

#26

J. Mattingly

J. Mattingly 1845 Private Barrel Select Light Whiskey "Make It Stop LOL"

Whiskey Other Whiskey USA

3.77

1 rating

$$$$ $100 to $300 Luxury

#27

J. Mattingly

J. Mattingly 1845 Private Barrel Select Light Whiskey "Living Proof"

Whiskey Other Whiskey USA 69.3% ABV

3.77

2 ratings

$$$$ $100 to $300 Luxury

#28

J. Mattingly

J. Mattingly 1845 Single Barrel Bourbon (Ripcord)

Whiskey Bourbon USA 55% ABV

3.77

2 ratings

$$$$ $100 to $300 Luxury

#29

J. Mattingly

J. Mattingly 1845 Private Barrel Select Light Whiskey "Magnitude"

Whiskey Other Whiskey USA 68.5% ABV

3.76

2 ratings

$$$$ $100 to $300 Luxury

#30

J. Mattingly

J. Mattingly 1845 Private Barrel Select Rye "Brothers Rye'd Together"

Whiskey Rye USA 57% ABV

3.76

1 rating

$ Under $30 Budget

#31

J. Mattingly

J Mattingly Open Doors Limited Edition Private Blend Select Bourbon Whiskey

Whiskey Bourbon Kentucky 61% ABV

3.76

3 ratings

$$$$ $100 to $300 Luxury

#32

J. Mattingly

J Mattingly 1845 Single Barrel Bourbon Sweet Tart 68th bottle

Whiskey American Blended Whiskey USA 59.5% ABV

3.76

4 ratings

$$$$ $100 to $300 Luxury

#33

J. Mattingly

J Mattingly 1845 Pineapple Cake Small Batch Light Whiskey

Whiskey Flavored Whiskey Kentucky 66.5% ABV

3.75

1 rating

$$$ $50 to $100 Premium

#34

J. Mattingly

J. Mattingly 1845 Private Barrel Select Light Whiskey "Marfa Lights"

Whiskey Other Whiskey USA 66.5% ABV

3.75

1 rating

$$$$ $100 to $300 Luxury

#35

J. Mattingly

J. Mattingly 1845 Private Barrel Select Light Whiskey "But They Were Suited"

Whiskey Other Whiskey Kentucky 59% ABV

3.74

1 rating

$$ $30 to $50 Everyday

#36

J. Mattingly

J. Mattingly 1845 Private Barrel Select Rye "Lynda"

Whiskey Rye Kentucky 58% ABV

3.72

2 ratings

$$$$ $100 to $300 Luxury

#37

J. Mattingly

J. Mattingly 1845 Single Barrel Straight Rye

Whiskey Rye USA 64.5% ABV

3.69

8 ratings

$$$$ $100 to $300 Luxury

#38

J. Mattingly

J. Mattingly Greater Cincinnati limited edition, private barrel, select, small batch, light, whiskey, colored and flavored with oak staves

Whiskey American Blended Whiskey Indiana 63% ABV

—

Not rated yet

$$$ $50 to $100 Premium

#39

J. Mattingly

J. Mattingly Greater Cincinnati Limited Edition Private Barrel Select Small Batch Rye Whiskey flavored with Oak Staves

Whiskey Rye Indiana 58% ABV

—

Not rated yet

$$$ $50 to $100 Premium

#40

J. Mattingly

J. Mattingly Double Staved 6-Year-old Kentucky Bourbon Whiskey Finished with Oak Staves

Whiskey Bourbon Kentucky 58% ABV

—

Not rated yet

$$$ $50 to $100 Premium

#41

J. Mattingly

J Mattingly 1845 - Bourbon 30 "It's That Time"

Whiskey Bourbon Kentucky 50% ABV

—

Not rated yet

$$$ $50 to $100 Premium

#42

J. Mattingly

J. Mattingly "Pour Decisions" Custom batch finished with oak staves

Whiskey Bourbon Kentucky 60% ABV

—

Not rated yet

$$$$ $100 to $300 Luxury

#43

J. Mattingly

J Mattingly 1845 Welcome Home Vietnam Veterans

Whiskey Other Whiskey Kentucky 64% ABV

—

Not rated yet

$$$ $50 to $100 Premium

#44

J. Mattingly

J Mattingly 1845 No Rye'm or Reason

Whiskey Rye Kentucky 58% ABV

—

Not rated yet

$$ $30 to $50 Everyday

#45

J. Mattingly

J. Mattingly Rye'lly Rd LE Private Barrel Select

Whiskey Rye Kentucky 100% ABV

—

Not rated yet

$ Under $30 Budget

#46

J. Mattingly

J. Mattingly 1845 Limited Edition Private Barrel Select "Imperial's Sweet Wheat"

Whiskey Bourbon Kentucky 57% ABV

—

Not rated yet

$$$$ $100 to $300 Luxury

#47

J. Mattingly

J. Mattingly one hell of a pick

Whiskey Bourbon Kentucky 58% ABV

—

Not rated yet

$ Under $30 Budget

#48

J. Mattingly

j mattingly private barrel sekect chuck's X toasted

Whiskey Bourbon Kwntucky 57.5% ABV

—

Not rated yet

$$$$ $100 to $300 Luxury

Filters · 1

Best of the range

Highest weighted scores from this brand.

J. Mattingly

J. Mattingly 1845 Private Barrel Select Light Whiskey "LFQ"

Other Whiskey USA

4.9 /5 3 $$$$

J. Mattingly

J Mattingly 1845 Limited Edition Private Barrel Select Small Batch Finished with Oak Staves

Bourbon Kentucky

4.7 /5 3 $$$$

J. Mattingly

J. Mattingly 1845 Private Barrel Select Bourbon "Pandemic Special"

Bourbon USA

5.0 /5 2 $$$$

J. Mattingly

J. Mattingly 1845 Private Barrel Select Light Whiskey "Get Your Rox Off"

Other Whiskey USA

4.9 /5 2 $$$$

J. Mattingly

J Mattingly 1845 Ballpark Bourbon Limited Edition Private Barrel Select Small Batch

Bourbon Kentucky

4.3 /5 4 $$$$

J. Mattingly

J. Mattingly 1845 Wheated Single Barrel

Bourbon MGP

4.4 /5 3 $$$$