On a trip to Boston, I agonized over what bottle to bring home. I'm heavily biased towards a local pick, so I selected the Bully Boy Distillers Private Cask, batch #5 bottle #58. The nose is deep, rich, and reminds me of maraschino cherries in syrup, rounded out by oak. Over time, a prominent vanilla tone makes a complimentary appearance. I generally enjoy sherry cask whiskies so this "blend of straight whiskies finished in Port and Madeira barrels" feels like a close friend to them. The first part of my sip coats my tongue with a syrupy sensation. The cask flavours are front and center with a touch of heat. There's a hint of spiced pear when inhaled on the palate. There aren't too many layers beyond but it's an enjoyable post-dinner dram. Medium, dry, belly-warming finish. 7.5/10
3.76
Reviews
Showing the most detailed of 3 parsed reviews.
redlipwhiskydiary
3.8
Aged One
4.0
Fresh rolls and vanilla cream. Soft feel with a nice warmth. Lingering vanilla laced with red wine.
Keith Kirchoff
3.8
Cinnamon, oak, mellow. Baked apple. Delicious, though not overly complex
Tastes like this
Same style and price bracket, best rated first.