Skip to content
Spirlix
Mayor Pingree 5 Year Single Barrel Red Label Bourbon
Mayor Pingree

Mayor Pingree 5 Year Single Barrel Red Label Bourbon

Whiskey Bourbon Michigan 5 Year 60% ABV
$$$ $50 to $100 Premium
7 reviews raw average 4.14

Reviews

Showing the most detailed of 2 parsed reviews.

hansmootho 3.8

I know it's not a southern U.S. bourbon, but I really enjoy the standard Mayor from Valentine in Michigan. I usually have a bottle open for an occasional pour. This bottle was a special relase as single barrels to high volume stores. Seeing a barrel strength offering was right up my alley and took some searching since they didn't last long on the shelves. Nose on this is a bit deceiving because there isn't a heavy ethanol presence despite the high proof. Definitely sense some vanilla and maybe a hint of cinnamon. First sip comes like a crescendo of flavor and heat. An intial hint of vanilla gives way to a bit of burnt caramel. There is almost a smokiness in this that you wouldn't expect from an American whiskey. Overall I didn't like this nearly as much as I hoped and it was not nearly as good as the 5 yr Rye released at the same time. I wanted to love this, but only found it to be pretty good.

Alex Gajewski 5.0

Excellent! Drank at alto bar

Tastes like this

Same style and price bracket, best rated first.

All Bourbon