Nose: oak and brown sugar Palate: taste a bit young but that’s not bad in this case. I get oak and vanilla and some tobacco. It’s solid. Finish: at 104 proof it had a bit of a hug. It linger on your tongue rather than that deep chest hug love that you get from higher proofs. Overall: it’s a solid pour. For me it’s not as good as their batch 6 cask strength or their Texas select toasted barrel. This is a solid pour. 3.6/5 stars. Glad I found a bottle.
About this bottle
For this first expression in the series, Penelope four grain straight bourbon is finished with two styles of French oak staves — a delicate stave with lower tannins and an intense stave with moderate tannins. Aged 4-5 years overall, it is bottled without chill-filtration at 104 proof.
Reviews
Showing the most detailed of 42 parsed reviews.
Ethanol on nose at first. Takes a minute to settle down and burn off. Once this sits there is a good amount of vanilla and caramel with hints of oak on the nose. First sip is smooth with a good after bite of black pepper and a leathery char. Ice calms peppery burn and makes this a dangerous offering with a higher proof. There is a long late burn but adds to the intensity and interest. I recommend this one!
Smells wheated with vanilla and spice. Taste comes in smooth and sweet but not overly so with notes of caramel, vanilla and oak but has a really good mouthfeel and balance to it. Finish moves very nicely into some spice that isn’t overly hot, especially for 104 proof. Initial impression is quite exceptional.
Nose: butterscotch, oak, caramel. Palate: mild barrel tannins, vanilla, caramel. Overall: the nose was much more impressive than the palate, and was a litttle underwhelmed with the taste. Still a good whiskey, but would not purchase again.
Nice butterscotch, vanilla and caramel flavors but drinks hotter than 104 proof with a lot of spice. The nose is delicious with sweet caramel and acetone. On the palate it is nice but has a short finish and heavy “hug.”
Nose: tart cherry and caramel, very heavy and sweet, good pop of vanilla Taste: warming oak with a nice cherry and spice. Relatively straight forward Finish: moderate, light finish with a slight tannin bitterness
36 more reviews were collected for this bottle. The longest ones are shown first.
Tastes like this
Same style and price bracket, best rated first.