I'm not sure if it deserved all the hate. Oak charcoal, corn pops cereal, boiled grains, lot of dutch cocoa, tobacco, black pepper, allspice, anise, heather honey, graham crackers, nutty, cream soda, ginger chews, candied pecans, brown butter, lemon peel. More medium than heavy but it does need some oxidation before opening up. Promised and delivered smoke while managing to balance it quite well. Would've liked to see a higher abv and another 1-3yrs.
About this bottle
This expression is produced from a mash bill of NY state-grown corn, smoked malted barley, and chocolate malt. It is matured in new, American oak with a #3 char. It is then bottled at 90 proof.
Reviews
Showing the most detailed of 14 parsed reviews.
Almost undrinkable. The smokiness is overpowering. I am able to drink any Islay Scotch and be satisfied but this can’t even be cut with ginger ale or coke. Save your money. Southern Tier does have a nice American whiskey. Look in that direction or another distiller.
Different. The sharp medicinal taste of the young whiskey doesn’t exactly combine smoothly with the smoke, and the bourbon sweetness is a bit buried. It’s not a harmonious dram. But it’s drinkable and interesting
Nose apple, ash corn, rye, light smoke. Palate is rye forward, corn, wood, ash. Short finish. Young, but smooth and interesting.
Hints of smoke... not over powering... pepper... tobacco... faintly sweet ... nice crisp finish.
Smokey flavor unusual for Bourbon. It masks much of the bourbon flavor and notes.
8 more reviews were collected for this bottle. The longest ones are shown first.
Tastes like this
Same style and price bracket, best rated first.