#409
The short list
Top rated spirits 3,560 bottles
Ranked by a weighted score that pools community reviews with critic scores and pulls thin evidence back toward the average. Every bottle here carries at least 40 reviews, so nothing arrives on the strength of one glowing rating.
3.80median score
$$typical price
1.2Mratings
#409
Elijah Craig
4.19
86 ratings
Top 6% of whiskey
$$$
$50 to $100 Premium
#410
4.19
72 ratings
Top 8% of agave
$$$$
$100 to $300 Luxury
Old Forester
Old Forester Single Barrel Rye Barrel Proof
4.19
110 ratings
Top 6% of whiskey
$$$
$50 to $100 Premium
#412
Bomberger's Declaration
Bomberger's Declaration (2020 Release)
4.19
61 ratings
Top 6% of whiskey
$$$
$50 to $100 Premium
Great value
#413
#413
Weller
Weller CYPB
4.19
557 ratings
Top 6% of whiskey
$$
$30 to $50 Everyday
#414
Bareksten
Bareksten Botanical Gin
4.19
42 ratings
Top 6% of gin
$$$$$
$300 and up Collector
#415
4.19
41 ratings
Top 6% of whiskey
$$$$
$100 to $300 Luxury
#416
Elijah Craig
Elijah Craig Barrel Proof Bourbon Batch A120
Tastes likeSpicy, Full Bodied, Rich, Sweet
4.19
183 ratings
Top 6% of whiskey
$$$
$50 to $100 Premium
#417
Old Fitzgerald
Old Fitzgerald 14 Year Bottled in Bond Bourbon (Fall 2020)
Tastes likeSweet, Rich, Full Bodied, Fruity
4.19
95 ratings
Top 6% of whiskey
$$$$
$100 to $300 Luxury
#418
4.19
74 ratings
Top 6% of whiskey
$$$$
$100 to $300 Luxury
#419
4.19
72 ratings
Top 6% of whiskey
$$$$
$100 to $300 Luxury
Top 5%
#420
#420
4.19
45 ratings
Top 5% of rum
$$$
$50 to $100 Premium
#421
4.19
2,721 ratings
Top 6% of whiskey
$$$$
$100 to $300 Luxury
#422
4.19
92 ratings
Top 6% of whiskey
$$$$
$100 to $300 Luxury
#423
Woodford Reserve
Woodford Reserve Master's Collection Batch Proof 118.4
Tastes likeVanilla, Rich, Full Bodied, Tart
4.19
63 ratings
Top 6% of whiskey
$$$$
$100 to $300 Luxury
#424
4.19
245 ratings
Top 6% of whiskey
$$$$
$100 to $300 Luxury
#425
Old Fitzgerald
Old Fitzgerald 15 Year Bottled in Bond Bourbon (Fall 2019)
Tastes likeSpicy, Herbal, Full Bodied, Tart
4.19
143 ratings
Top 6% of whiskey
$$$$
$100 to $300 Luxury
#426
4.19
107 ratings
Top 6% of whiskey
$$$$
$100 to $300 Luxury
#427
4.19
127 ratings
Top 6% of whiskey
$$$$
$100 to $300 Luxury
#428
George
George Dickel x Leopold Bros Collaboration Blend (2021 Release)
Tastes likeSpicy, Herbal, Rich, Fruity
4.19
115 ratings
Top 6% of whiskey
$$$$
$100 to $300 Luxury
#429
Michter's
Michter's 10 Year Single Barrel Kentucky Straight Bourbon (2023 Release)
Tastes likeFull Bodied, Rich, Sweet
4.19
49 ratings
Top 6% of whiskey
$$$$$
$300 and up Collector
#430
4.18
930 ratings
Top 6% of whiskey
$$$$
$100 to $300 Luxury
#431
4.18
442 ratings
Top 6% of whiskey
$$$
$50 to $100 Premium
#432
Octomore
Octomore 07.2/208 Cask Evolution
4.18
79 ratings
Top 6% of whiskey
$$$$$
$300 and up Collector