I'm of the opinion that rum should be created (very much like whiskey) with the goal of being something great to sip on neat or in an old fashioned. As a whiskey fan there are many rums that accomplish this. This rum is not one of them. As I toured the distillery while in New Orleans the tour guide drove home repeatedly that this rum was crafted with the intent of being a mixer. And to be fair, it's pretty good at that! Yet, again, in my personal opinion any aged liquor should be made with the intent of it being great neat or on the rocks. If your start with a great product your cocktails will be that much better.
About this bottle
Housed in a 150-year-old cotton warehouse in an industrial area of the city north of the famous French Quarter, the Old New Orleans rum distillery was one of the first entries in the new wave of American craft distilling. Old New Orleans is derived without the use of additives or coloring. It is 100% natural using high-grade cane syrup in a slow batch process. The sugarcane is sourced from one farmer, Greg Nolan at LaFouche Sugars in Thibodaux. Old New Orleans Amber is a blend of aged rum and spends up to three years in charred American oak barrels previously used for aging whiskey.
How it tastes
Measured across 14 flavor axes. Tap a note to find other bottles that lead with it.
Reviews
Showing the most detailed of 4 parsed reviews.
Aroma is butterscotch with a sharp and spicy, clove maybe, twang. Followed by something oily and burtb/roasted toffee. Flavor is different from pretty much anything else I've had so far. Grassy/funky with a baked goods (maybe sugar cookie) finish. In general, can be overwhelming straight, ice calms it down. Even though I'm mentioning sweet things, this isn't a sweet rum. Honestly not that enjoyable on its own, but then even the distiller calls it a mixing rum.
Color is a nice amber. Nose is slightly strong on the ethanol initially. As the etanol fades, notes of sugar and butterscotch appear, though they are covered by a strong oily essence that is a little off-putting. First sip is oily, with rich notes of charred oak and mild sweetness, with very subtle butterscotch. Finishes with mild baking spice. Almost no burn, very smooth. Overall pretty good for the price.
Not as sweet as most rum but still flavorful. Very smooth, easy to drink.
Tastes like this
Closest flavor profiles across the whole catalog.